Thursday, February 24, 2011

Working Visit by YM Dato Raja Azahar, Deputy Secretary General Ministry of Home Affairs to PJ JPN Office


Dato Raja Azahar togther with community leaders at JPN-PJ

The Deputy Secretary General arrived at 11am to the Federal government building in New Town PJ on Feb 24, 2011 (Thursday). It is now five days into the ‘My daftar campaign’. PJ office has been very busy as the Petaling district covers a wider area and many Indians are residing here especially in low cost- high rise flats.


Mr Padma of Lembah Subang presenting a souvenir to Dato Raja
 Before Dato Raja Azahar entered the JPN building he was greeted by Lembah Subang community leader and residents who had come in two buses to make their submissions. The Selangor MIC has organized the bus as well as a commissioner of oath to certify many of the documents prior to their submission at JPN today.

During the course of his working visit and press conference Dato Raja Azahar said that he made this special effort to give moral support to JPN officers who have been hard at work and also have ground knowledge of the developments and issues. He acknowledged that JPN officers are playing an very important role in assisting the people.

In addition he acknowledged that a good feature of this campaign was the role played by political parties, voluntary and religious organisations. This he saw personally when he spoke to the people from Lembah Subang who had come to make their submissions

Dato Raja Azahar recognized that one of the major problems in the community is the lack of awareness among the poorer sections of the Indian community in ensuring that they secure the necessary documents. Citizenship documents are of utmost importance to ensure that ordinary people can exercise the citizenship rights and responsibilities.

He admitted that while the My daftar has brought to public light the documentation issues, however there is lots more work to be done to ensure that in the processing period the applicants fulfill all the basic requirements and secures supporting documents. He noted that in some cases this might be difficult and therefore on a case by case basic Putrajaya could review the applications.

Dato reviewing some files with JPN Selangor Director Tuan Hj Mustapaha
He also recognized that in the post campaign period and in order to strengthen the solving the cases, contract officers may need to be appointed. He added that the Taskforce could request the Federal government for addition funds to try and resolve all cases within this year. Some of the retired JPN officers could be recruited to assist in this process.

Also present were PM’s special Indian officer Datuk Ravin Ponniah, MIC Selangor Deputy Chairman Dato Gopalkrishan, MIC Selangor co ordinator Mr Siva Subramaniam and Taskforce secretary, Datuk Dr Denison Jayasooria

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Economic Development Programmes through SMEcorp

Munes, Jun, Premla, Denison, Meor & Mahdi at SMECorp (Feb 22, 2011)
SME Corp has come up with two very good products to support the business community.

  • One targets the micro business people called E2 –Enrichment & Enhancement Programme which are micro enterprises (MEs) registered with the Registration of Business Act, with less than RM 250,00 annual sales turn over and with less than 5 workers

  • The second targets SMEs which are bigger companies registered under the Companies Act (Sdn Bhd) with less that RM25 million annual sales and less than 150 workers in a programme called Business Accelerator Programme (BAP)
Visit to SMECorp

Yesterday Taskforce secretary Datuk Dr Denison Jayasooria together Taskforce officer Puan Premla Ravin visted SME Corp and met up with Mr Mahdi Mohd Ariffin, Deputy CEO and Mrs Muneswari Munusamy, Manager and Mr Meor Shahril, Asst Manager. Also present was Ms Junaidah Yusof, DFED, Bank Negara.

According to Dr Denison, he said it was a fruitful discussion and we learnt a lot concerning the SMECorp’s two new products. Once again we found out Indian community’s awareness on these are limited and there is very little coordinated effort to expose the community to many of these initiatives.

This visit has enabled the Taskforce to secure the basic information and details for further dissemination and also to ensure increased Indian participation. Taskforce will organize a meeting for leaders from Indian business associations and with their cooperation facilitate awareness programmes on the ground.

The Taskforce will give special emphasis to assist the informal and micro business players on the ground as a majority of the MEs are people at the bottom of the socio-economic ladder especially at the bottom 40%

Some interesting features of these programmes. There are 4 different aspects:-

  • Feature 1 - DIAGNOSTICS

When a person applies on to their online registration and provides basic information a visit is made by an SMR Corp officer. An assessment is made to note strengthens and shortcomings. The evaluator will also draw up a plan of action for the business person to address the short falls in order to strengthen their competitiveness.

  • Feature 2 – CAPACITY BUILDING

Based on the diagnostic tool used capacity building programmes will be recommended. SMEcorp has 40 approved training centres and the business person can enroll in any one of them. These can be skills based or awareness on branding.

  • Feature 3 – ADVISORY & TECHNICAL SUPPORT

Two types of services provided. A One Referral Centre (ORC) provides advisory services for start ups and also established businesses. There is also an SME Expert Advisory Panel (SEAP) on various fields. This counseling, advisory and technical support is very useful and helpful in molding and grooming Indian business. These have to be utilized.


  • Feature 4 – FACILITATING ACCESS TO FINANCING

SMEcorp provides both grants and soft loans. This aspect will be attractive. However the loans or grants are not automatic but based on Feature 1 –results of the diagnostic test.

For MEs soft loans and grants are available for below RM50, 000. Loans are at a 5% interest. For SME it is above RM50, 000 but below RM 500,000 at 4% interest rate. When a loan is approved then 40% of this could become a grant provided by the Federal government. The loans for MEs are administered by Bank Rakyat and the loans for SMEs by MIDF (Malaysian Industrial Development Finance)

Taskforce Role

The Taskforce will ensure that the information is disseminated and will call up the Indian business community at the micro –formal and informal together with the SME’s to plug into the system and take advantage of the programmes made available by the Federal government.

Local community response to My Daftar campaign

Tuan Haji Raham, Mr Padma and Ebenezer reviewing applications at Lembah Subang
The Lembah Subang local community leaders headed by Mr Padmanagan have been very busy in assisting residents in filling the JPN forms during this campaign period. This is a very good example of local leaders taking action in addressing local needs.

Mr Padma is a local MIC leader. He has been living in this neighbourhood for the past 10 years running a market stall with his wife. He seems to know every one especially the Indian community. It was he and his local committee that hosted a program on Feb 15, 2011 which was officiated by Datuk Dr Subramaniam, The Taskforce Chairman and Human Resources Ministry.

Mr Padma assisting Tuan Hj Rahaman at Lembah Subang
Mr Padma had earlier attended a training session on JPN form filling at the JPN office at PJ. He had gone and met the officer in charge and gathered all the forms needed. He sought the assistance of volunteers to fill the forms too.

Yesterday Feb 22, 2011 (Tuesday) he organized a gathering at the community hall and invited Tuan Hj Abdul Rahaman to come and review all the applications with the persons concerned. This is a very useful process as it saves time and ensures that when the people come and submit on Feb 24, 2011 (Thursday) they will be complete or at least near completion. Any major complication or difficulty is then cleared early and assistance sought especially for some leader to take an oath that he knows this individual concerned.

Tuan Hj Abdul Rahman the JPN officer in PJ has gone out of the way by coming after office hours to local community halls to meet people and explain to them the requirements and advice on how to fill the forms. He did this some time back with the community at Desa Mentari block 9 and 10.

Tuan Haj Rahaman's friendly approach wins 'hearts & minds' at Lembah Subang
Tuan Haji, tries to use the little Tamil he knows. He grew up in Bangsar and lived among Indians as his father worked in the railways. He has taken an extra mile. This exemplary service is bridging the gap between the people on the bottom and Putrajaya. Through his personal service he has enabled ordinary people feel at home and recognize that JPN and the Federal government cares for them.

Saturday, February 19, 2011

Mass movement of Indians – not for protest but problem solving

On the first day at Maju Junction, KL (Feb 19)
- 1st day of My Daftar Campaign-

It is estimated that over 3, 418 people turned up on the first day of the “My daftar campaign”. JPN officers were available in 80 of their office centres this weekend. People were coming out in unbelievable numbers.

It can be said that this is a mass movement of Indians not to protest but resolve their grievances. We are also seeing large number of volunteers from a variety of organizations also responding to address this human need and right for documents and citizenship.

Maju Junction

People gathering outside JPN Maju Junction (Feb 19, 2011)
 At Maju Junction in Kuala Lumpur over a thousand people came on the first day of the campaign with a hope in their hearts that this time the Federal government which has undertaken this Nation wide campaign to identify and resolve the concerns of undocumented Malaysians.


A large number of people gathered inside Maju Junction (Feb 19, 2011)
As at 2.30pm on Feb 19, 2011, total of 606 cases were received at JPN, WP KL:-

  • BC application  :           136
  • IC applications :             82
  • Citizenship        :           388

At the Press Conference, Maju Junction (Feb 19, 2011)
Datuk Dr Subramaniam, Datuk Saravanan & Dato Devamani all visited JPN office at Maju Junction. They walked around the sixth floor of the Maju Junction JPN KL office and met the people, officers and volunteers.

During the press conference, the Minister highlighted that one major area is regarding citizenship. He narrated that during his ‘walk about’ there were many elderly in their 50s and 60s who are Red IC card holders seeking for a Blue IC cards. He also told that the Taskforce will review this matter of Red card holders and make specific recommendations to the Federal government.

The Minister also indicated to a media question that when Feb 26 comes which is the last day of the campaign it is in fact the beginning of Taskforce duties as we will seek to resolve them. Many of the cases are complicated as the people are unable to secure the supporting documents. He also said that the Taskforce is setting a 6 months timeframe to ensure the follow up strategies are effectively resolved.

At Maju Junction it was the coming together of an unbelievable number of people. They have come with hope and confidence. Therefore the Taskforce is really under pressure in ensuring a majority of registered cases will secure a favorable answer.

Friday, February 18, 2011

My Daftar campaign Begins Today Feb 19 (Sat) till Feb 26 (sat).



Local community leaders at Lembah Subang, PJ handing over a list of 90 local residents
without relvant documents to Taskforce Chair Datuk Dr Subramaniam on Feb 15, 2011  .
  The Campaign organized by the Taskforce (PM Dept) with the cooperation of the Ministry of Home Affairs, Department of Registration and Department of Information is a major National campaign organized by the Federal Government

It starts today on Feb 19 till 26, 2011. The Department of National Registration has provided utmost cooperation by opening up 80 offices in 9 states in Malaysia. This is the largest and comprehensive campaign organized so far.

This is a major effort to identify all the undocumented Malaysian Indians so that through this campaign they

  • Can be identified especially those with out birth certificates or identification cards
  • Can be assisted to fill the relevant forms
  • Can be assisted to secure supporting information and details on origin and birth
  • Can be successful as people who can eventually secure all the legal documents and thereby enjoy their rights as Malaysian citizens

Datuk Dr Subramaniam, the Taskforce chair & Minister together with Datuk Saravanan the Deputy Minister will undertake a working visit to the JPN office at Maju Junction today Feb 19, 2011 at 12noon.

Similar programs and launches are being organized at all the major states where the campaign is being undertaken.

Thus far the Taskforce has received tremendous support from political parties, community groups, private sector leaders and NGOs. This is a mass mobilization of the community and there is a concerted effort from many different quarters.

Micro Credit Awareness Program at Seremban


Participants at the Seremban Micro Finance Program
 The Taskforce organized a third micro credit awareness program with speakers from AKPK, BSN and Agro bank. The earlier ones were in Perai and Kapar. Over 85 people came to the Seremban program on Saturday, Feb 12, 2011 which was held at the MIC State office with a majority being men namely 58 and the remaining 27 were women.

Micro Business experience

It is interesting to note that many are already undertaking micro or small business. Some were undertaking transportation enterprise, or running a bridal set up and others selling eatables such as ‘nasi lemak’ or sales pertaining to flowers or prayer items or in direct selling in health care products.

Among the two people who interacted with Datuk Dr Denison were Mr S Harikrishan and Mr K Ramani. Both are very successful businessmen. In the case of Hari he runs a cleaning service and Mr Ramani manages small plantations on lease. Both seem to be in a good business area and so far they have grown from very small using personal funds and resources. Both admit that access to loans is an issue and their financial management styles and approaches are a problem for formal banking. However they both recognize that in order for them to grow they need to

  • Reorganise their business
  • Develop more professional approaches
  • Standardize financial and banking practices
  • Develop credit discipline

Issue of high interest

A major issue raised at the Sermeban gathering  was regarding to why is the interest rates for BSN and Agro bank was so high namely between 14 to 17%? A number raised this concern and there was some reluctance to applying for this loan.

The bank officials indicated that the cost of micro loans are high and therefore to cover their cost they have to charge this interest rate. In addition there is the high risk factor too. The people however feel that it is the duty of the Federal government to assist micro and small players in the market with just interest say 4 to 7 % rather than 14 to 17%.

Both Hari and Ramai were looking forward to special schemes by the Federal government which is in the interest of building micro and small Indian businesses.

Talk on Financial Management

The participants were very delighted with the AKPK speaker Mr Segaran and his presentation on financial management. One participant indicated that one hour is insufficient and that more sessions must be held on how to manage our finance. Mr Steven of Sermeban MIC and who was one of the local organisers has asked the Taskforce to organize another two to three hours program on financial management and he has assured to being over 30 young people.

For the Taskforce team this is a learning curve in order to pilot test especially in areas such as micro enterprise awareness, access to available micro credit loans and acquiring good financial management information and procedures. There is a need for a national scheme to update and upgrade micro Indian business operators so that their potential can be tap for wealth creation and improvement of the quality of life index among the bottom 40% in the Indian community.

Sunday, February 13, 2011

The hidden poor in a city of affluence

Public Housing Flats at Air Panas
Three Indian Women in need 

Yesterday (Feb 13, 2011) during a visit to the DBKL flats at Air Panas, Setiawangsa, KL I met three women who shared their experience of urban poverty which provides a picture of the complex nature of urban poverty. However there are no public sector agencies or NGOs that addresses these urban poor concerns in a systematic and holistic way.

There are eights blocks of high rise flats in this neighborhood with over 2,565 units. Of these 35% are occupied by Indian families. These families were shifted from previous squatters in this region. The families originally lived and worked in two estates located in this area namely Wardiban Estate and Hawthonan Estate. The families were displaced and they lived in squatters after the estate was sold for development.

Now they have been resettled into new public housing provided by KL city hall and the monthly rent is RM124.00 The flats looks new and well kept by city hall. The infrastructure looks pleasant however when we chat with ordinary people we come to understand human suffering in these urban locations with very little public and community facilities. These people are among the new and hidden poor admits our rich city and land. Many suffer daily with very little sense of hope as reflected in the three women whom I met yesterday.

Mrs Shanti Subramaniam (35). She has got 5 children. He husband left her, one and half years ago. Her oldest daughter is 17 years old and not in school. However the remaining four are going to school. She works in a near by company and earns RM800. When her husband left her, he left her with two debts she now has to settle. One is for RM4, 244.50 which is house rent. They have not paid for nearly 5 years and are now at risk of being thrown out by city hall as she has received the notice for eviction.



Left to right - Parathy, Shanti & Puspavathy
 She also has inherited a debt of RM3,000 from an Along (illegal money lender) and her ATM card and bank book is now in the possession of the along who monthly with draws RM300.00 She is unsure how long more she has to pay and seems confused over how much she has paid.

Shanti might not be statistically poor based on Malaysian PLI measurement but definitely in Amarty Sen’s definition unable to break the cycle of poverty. She is an extremely vulnerable single mother in the city. She told me so many time she too has thought of either running away or taking her life as there seems to be no way out of the hands of illegal money lenders and financial debt.

This reality of poverty is not been captured by any of the state intervention programs in social welfare or Azam as the complexities of urban poverty are not serious taken into account in the design of intervention programs. The answer too is not to just give Shanti the needed RM7,000 to get her out of poverty but also assist her through some self help group which will provide support and some training on home budget and finance.

Mrs Parathy (42) also has five children between the ages 21 to 12. Her husband was driving a taxi but because of a loan from an along (illegal money lender) their lives have been disrupted. They borrowed to make a down payment for taxi rental but are caught in difficulties in repayments. Monthly they are paying RM250 and according to Parthy this is only to service the interest. They have been doing this for the past 2 years and there seems to be no end to this bondage.

The ugly aspect of the illegal money lender emerged when they posted a huge photocopy of his identification card in front of the house with red paint saying they have borrowed and unable to replay and that the family is untrustworthy. They felt so ashamed among their neighbors that they now pay the interest but the principle sum is unsettled yet. It seems never ending. They do not seems to get any support from any authorities like Police or city hall enforcement who are in the know of illegal activities.

Another lady who spoke to me is Mrs Puspavathy (in her 50s). She is a widow with one son who is unemployed. They have not been able to settle the house rental and owe city hall RM1, 270. She works at a plastic company and earns RM660.00 a month. She has been doing so for the past 23 years. Her salary is really low however this is what she and her son survives on.

Measuring poverty beyond an income measure

Malaysia continues to use an income measure to ascertain poverty. The Poverty Line Income (PLI) is a means income test. Malaysia sets poverty at RM750.00 and below. However globally there is a major shift in poverty measurement instruments and while income measurement is only used as one among many indicators rather than it being the sole indicator.

Together with Prof Amartya Sen at Delhi airport
A major advocate of this change in measuring instruments is Prof Amarty Sen. Recently I had the good fortune of meeting him at New Delhi airport and briefly chatted with him on this matter.

His land mark work entitled ‘Development as Freedom’, where he states “poverty as a deprivation of basic capabilities, rather than merely as low income” (pg 20). He advocates a shift “from an exclusive concentration on income poverty to the more inclusive idea of capability deprivation, we can better understand the poverty of human lives and freedoms” (pg 20)

These three stories call us to review social intervention strategies among the urban poor. We need to clearly articulate the issues and concerns and draw up initiatives which can empower people to realize their full potential.